xs
This website uses cookies to ensure you get the best experience on our website. Learn more
Law Cases
Contract Law Cases
Damages Cases

Re The Golden Victory [2007] 2 WLR 691

Country:
United Kingdom
By Oxbridge Law Team
Lord Scott
Lord Bingham (dis...

  • Defendant hired a boat from Plaintiff but breached the contract by returning it 4 years before the charter was set to end. 14 months later, the Gulf war broke out, which would have entitled Defendant to end the contract anyway.

  • Plaintiff claimed for 4 years of damages.

  • HL ruled that only 14 months worth of damages were payable since the aim was to put the claimant in the position that they would have been in had the contractual performance been fulfilled, and in doing this it couldn’t shut its eyes to future events. 

Lord Scott

  • He applies the dictum of Parke B and hence says that what loss is actually caused is the relevant factor. Otherwise the courts would be giving people awards beyond their loss i.e. overcompensating. 

Lord Bingham (dissenting)

  • Points in response to Lord Scott:

    1. To make people pay for the full amount is a deterrent to breach of contract;

    2. Certainty is important in business, so that if there is a breach, Plaintiff must be able to work out, before entering the contract, what he will be entitled to. 

Any comments or edits about this case?
Get in touch

Similar cases

Suisse Atlantique v Rotterdamsche Kolen
Defendant chartered a boat off Plaintiff with a contractual term that Defendant had to finish loading at each port within a specified time limit. When Defendant failed to unload in several ports with...
Jackson v Royal Bank of Scotland
J sold goods to X, until R accidentally leaked information on the extent of J’s mark-up (in breach of J and R’s confidentiality contract) and as a result X ceased to do business with J. J sued R. HL...
Golden Strait Corporation v Nippon Kubishika Kaisha (The Golden Victory)
Damages should be assessed at the date of the trial rather than at the date of the breach or any intervening events. This approach ensures a fair and objective evaluation of damages, free from the in...
Re The Alaskan Trader
A chartered B’s boat and crew for 24 months but returned it after 12 since it needed extensive repairs that would take months and therefore claimed to repudiate the remainder of the contract. B refus...
Port Line v Ben Line
X contracted to give Plaintiff a charter, before selling the boat to Defandant. Defendant gave X a charter for the remaining period of P’s entitled use of the boat (so as to allow X to honour its con...

Related free notes samples

Monetary Remedies Notes
Shipping and International Trade Law notes fully updated for recent exams at Oxford. These note
The Alaskan Trader Notes
These are detailed case summaries (excerpts from cases - not paraphrased) I made during the

logo

Ambitious and intelligent students
choose Oxbridge Notes.

©2024 Oxbridge Notes. All right reserved.